NOTE! This site uses cookies

By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. For more detalis, see Read more


What are you looking for?

Major clash between government partners as president stripped of MP status

ERC accepts suspending Torra to avoid "risk of blocking parliament" while JxCat rejects it, warning of executive's "risk of collapsing"


27 January 2020 03:27 PM


Guifré Jordan | Barcelona

The Catalan government is stumbling. The reason for the latest major discrepancy between Junts per Catalunya and Esquerra is President Quim Torra's status as MP.

The Catalan parliament's top public servant, Xavier Muro, gave the order to withdraw Torra from his position as an MP on Monday morning – this followed the electoral board ordering the chamber to execute its ruling on Torra, which was later greenlighted by Spain's Supreme Court, despite him having a disqualification (pending appeal) from public office.

The parliament bureau, chaired by Esquerra's Roger Torrent, did not oppose Muro's move in its meeting in the early afternoon, despite Torra's party Junts per Catalunya rejecting it.

Given that Muro's order has not been contradicted by parliament speaker Torrent, Catalan News understands that the chamber accepts Torra is no longer an MP.

Speaker confirms Torra has no right to vote in chamber

Indeed, in a statement opening the plenary session on Monday afternoon, speaker Torrent said that Torra’s vote would not be counted during this session. "Otherwise it would mean paralyzing parliament." 

"We, the parliament, will fight to revoke the suspension," added Torrent, describing the electoral board’s ruling as "unfair." 

Immediately afterwards, Torra made a statement in the chamber, rejecting parliament’s move: "I hope parliament reverses its decision, otherwise institutions will be put at risk." 

Yet, this does not mean that the president is being stripped also as Catalonia's top authority, or at least not so far.

After Torrent confirmed that Quim Torra would not be able to vote on any parliamentary motion, Junts per Catalunya announced that they would not participate in any vote in the chamber today as a form of protest. 

Their motion on the parliamentary budget was then rejected with zero votes in favour.

Around 6 pm, speaker Torrent adjourned the plenary session until next week. 

  • "We, the parliament, will fight to revoke the suspension"

    Roger Torrent · Catalan parliament speaker

This discrepancy in the bureau between Esquerra and Junts per Catalunya puts the Catalan government at risk.

Esquerra, in favor of suspending Torra as MP

On the one hand, Esquerra accepted withdrawing the president’s parliament seat today to avoid a "risk of blocking parliament with all votes challenged," including that of the budget.

If Torra takes part in votes, right-wing unionist parties will very likely challenge them. 

Esquerra’s spokesperson Sergi Sabrià said that their aim is to “guarantee that Torra stays as president” but at the same time making sure votes on budget and other key issues for the country’s governance can move forward. Catalonia has not been able to pass a spending plan since 2017. 

JxCat, against stripping Torra

On the other hand, Torra’s party, JxCat, flatly rejected the removal of their leader as MP. 

Two of their senior MPs, Albert Batet and Josep Costa, called on the speaker to "guarantee Torra's seat" and said that otherwise "the government is at risk of collapsing."

“We have to warn that without Torra as MP, the continuity of the government and the budget are at risk,” they said on Monday afternoon.