Court chamber trying pro-independence leaders ‘controlled’ by PP, show leaked chats
Message from party spokesperson in Senate causes outrage
Spain’s People’s Party (PP) will "control from the behind the scenes" the trial prosecuting Catalan leaders for organizing a referendum on independence, according to leaked chats from the party’s spokesperson in the Senate.
In a Whatsapp message made public by ‘El Español’ online newspaper, Ignacio Cosidó told colleagues that the conservative party had secured influence over the Second Chamber of Spain’s Supreme Court following an agreement with their political foes, the ruling Socialist party of president Pedro Sánchez.
The revelations come after the two main parties in Congress reached a compromise last week over the renewal of judges at the helm of the Spanish judiciary, including its General Council (CGPJ) and the Supreme Court.
"[Ignacio Cosidó’s message] puts into words what we already knew: that Spain’s separation of powers is a mirage"
Pere Aragonès · Catalan vice president
Cosidó’s message is seen as an effort to dampen criticism within his party's ranks after judge Manuel Marchena was chosen as the would-be president of the CGPJ, thus delegating the task of conducting the trial of pro-independence leaders to the progressive judge, Andrés Martínez Arrieta.
Leaked chats were met with severe criticism, especially by pro-independence leaders. "[Cosidó’s message] puts into words what we already knew: that Spain’s separation of powers is a mirage," said Catalan vice president Pere Aragonès.
Una altra evidència que a l’estat espanyol la justícia és un mercadeig entre el PSOE i el PP i que l’estat de dret i les llibertats no estan garantides per a cap ciutadà. No hi ha independència judicial, ni imparcialitat ni integritat.https://t.co/4GQRX6kJRw— Quim Torra i Pla (@QuimTorraiPla) November 19, 2018
Catalan president Quim Torra said that "the rule of law and freedoms are not guaranteed" in Spain, where there’s neither "judicial independence, nor impartiality, nor integrity."
Later on the day, Cosidó told reporters that his message had been misinterpreted, but admitted that the words he used were "unfortunate." He stressed that he did not refer to PP when talking about "controlling" the judiciary, because "that’s not possible."
Cosidó ruled out stepping down after the anti-austerity Podemos party called for his resignation both as PP’s spokesperson and as a member of the Spanish Senate.
"Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás". Así defiende el portavoz del PP el vergonzoso pacto cerrado con PSOE-Podemos para repartirse a los jueces. Presumiendo con descaro de su mangoneo y de la pinza Sánchez-Casado contra una Justicia independiente. https://t.co/mlKgsTl1Et— Albert Rivera (@Albert_Rivera) November 19, 2018
Albert Rivera, the leader of Ciutadans, PP's main allies in Congress, deemed as "shameful" the deal between PP and the Socialists "against an independent judiciary."
Alberto Garzón, the leader of Izquierda Unida and Unidos Podemos’ second-in-command, also took on Cosidó. "Then it comes as a surprise that the judiciary is reactionary and partial," he said.